AI Overview vs AI Mode: what 20,000 prompts reveal about their sources and answers

by November 16, 20264 min read

✦ Key takeaway

We submitted the same 20,000 prompts to AI Overview and AI Mode to compare their sources. The result: the two Google AIs share only 17% of their cited domains on average, and 1 prompt in 4 has no domain in common. AI Overview relies on YouTube (11.4% of citations), AI Mode on French government websites (gouv.fr, 3.7%). Being visible in one guarantees nothing in the other.

AI Overview and AI Mode are both Google products, yet they almost never cite the same sources for the same question. Across more than 20,000 identical prompts, the two AIs share only 17% of their cited domains on average, and fewer than 1 prompt in 100 gets near-identical sources.

To measure this, we submitted exactly the same prompts to AI Overview and AI Mode in November 2026. The questions cover a wide range of topics: cars, tyres, energy and housing, banking and credit, government procedures, SEO, and more. We then compared the cited domains, prompt by prompt.

Key figures

The two AIs talk about the same topic, but not with the same sources or the same words.

Metric

AI Overview

AI Mode

Prompts analysed

20,000

20,000

Total URLs cited

153,961

81,654

Distinct domains cited

25,159

17,727

Distinct domains cited per prompt (average)

7.0

3.8

Share of citations going to the top 10 domains

19.5%

7.3%

Share of citations going to social and community platforms

17.7%

2.4%

And when we compare the two AIs prompt by prompt:

  • 16.9% average similarity of cited domains, and only 0.8% of prompts with near-identical sources (75% or more of domains in common).
  • 25.6% of prompts have no cited domain in common.
  • 1.4 shared domains per prompt on average.

Top general sources: YouTube dominates AI Overview, gouv.fr leads AI Mode

To compare general sources, we excluded brand websites, online retailers and comparison sites, and grouped all subdomains of gouv.fr (French government websites) and of Google. Shares are still calculated on all citations of each AI.

YouTube alone accounts for 11.4% of all AI Overview citations, compared with 1.1% in AI Mode. With 17,476 citations, it is cited almost 19 times more often in AI Overview. More broadly, social networks and video platforms take 7 of the 10 places in AI Overview's top 10.

AI Mode, on the other hand, relies first on public sources: gouv.fr websites capture 3.7% of its citations, compared with 2.2% in AI Overview. Google comes next (1.8%), followed by YouTube (1.1%). The rest of its top 10 gives more room to reviews (Que Choisir, a French consumer association, and Trustpilot), to media (Les Numériques, a French tech media) and to Wikipedia.


Rank

AI Overview

Share of citations

AI Mode

Share of citations

1

youtube.com

11.35%

gouv.fr (all subdomains)

3.67%

2

facebook.com

3.10%

Google (all subdomains)

1.76%

3

gouv.fr (all subdomains)

2.22%

youtube.com

1.14%

4

instagram.com

1.19%

reddit.com

0.54%

5

reddit.com

1.16%

quechoisir.org

0.37%

6

Google (all subdomains)

0.83%

fr.trustpilot.com

0.36%

7

tiktok.com

0.49%

facebook.com

0.33%

8

quechoisir.org

0.27%

lesnumeriques.com

0.29%

9

fr.linkedin.com

0.25%

fr.wikipedia.org

0.18%

10

dailymotion.com

0.22%

fr.linkedin.com

0.15%

7 domains appear in both top 10s: YouTube, Facebook, Reddit, gouv.fr, Google, Que Choisir and LinkedIn. The two AIs draw from the same major platforms, but in very different proportions.

Sources prompt by prompt: 1 prompt in 4 with no domain in common

For the same prompt, AI Overview and AI Mode share 16.9% of their cited domains on average. This score is the number of domains cited by both AIs, divided by the total number of distinct domains cited by either one.

In practice, AI Overview cites 7 domains per prompt on average and AI Mode almost 4. Only 1.4 domains appear on both sides.


Similarity of cited domains

Share of prompts

0% (no domain in common)

25.6%

Less than 25%

46.5%

25 to 50%

22.7%

50 to 75%

4.4%

75% or more (near-identical sources)

0.8%

At the exact URL level, the gap widens further: average similarity drops to 10.2% and 42.7% of prompts have no cited page in common. The two AIs sometimes go to the same website, but rarely to the same page.

What it means for your GEO strategy

Being visible in AI Overview does not guarantee visibility in AI Mode. You need to track and optimise both separately.

  • Measure both AIs separately. With only 17% of sources in common on average, a good score in one says almost nothing about the other.
  • Invest in video for AI Overview. YouTube captures more than 1 citation in 10: an active channel and videos that answer your customers' questions are a direct lever.
  • Take care of your own website for AI Mode. Its citations are more spread out and leave more room for brand websites, official sources and specialist retailers.
  • Work on pages, not just domains. 43% of prompts have no URL in common: each AI picks its own pages, even on a website they both cite.
  • Target the shared sources. Brand websites and official sources are cited by both AIs for the same prompt: this is the most solid foundation for visibility.

Measure your visibility in AI Overview and AI Mode

Search Ai measures, prompt by prompt, which sources generative AIs cite on your topics, and whether your brand is among them. Request a demo

Free audit

Is your site cited by ChatGPT?

About the author

Antonia Giarikani

R&D & IA, CPO Search Ai

Antonia is Chief Product Officer (CPO) of Search Ai, a Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) platform for measuring, managing, and optimizing brand visibility on generative AI engines such as ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, ... With over 10 years of experience as an R&D engineer, she continues to work at the intersection of R&D and business, transforming AI advancements into concrete functionalities for marketing teams.

← Back to blog

You might also enjoy